Friday, November 13, 2009

Narrative Imagination: The Open Closet

I’d like to start this blog with a reflection of service at the open closet last weekend. (Yes I actually had a day off work, and it happened to be the 1st Saturday of the month!) What an experience it was! When I arrived, there was a line of people from the door to the closet to the corner of the block who were waiting for free clothes at the closet. I never imagined seeing that many people who needed clothes so desperately. By serving in this setting, I finally had the chance to directly interact with MANY people from the Washington neighborhood. These people are really struggling (with the exception of a few who were abusing the service); their voices need to be heard by everyone in Dubuque.

A story about the lives of people who came to take a bagful of free clothes needs to be written. After it’s written, the whole Dubuque community needs to read it. The purpose of reading such a story is for the middle class citizens to experience circumstances that are unique to the ones they experience in their daily life. It is only by writing such literature that the remainder of the community will have the opportunity to better understand the struggles that the people in the Washington neighborhood face each and every day.

I am certain that Nussbaum agrees with the previous paragraph; that the literature becomes “the voice of the silenced people” (96). In addition, she would use words such as sympathy and compassion to describe what should be felt by others who read about these people from the neighborhood. Such a work of literature would work in creating “a sense of one’s own vulnerability to misfortune” (91). I feel that it would help to put everything into perspective; it might raise the questions: what is our purpose in life? What is really important to us? Why is there so much injustice in the world? And perhaps, what can I be doing as a human being to help eliminate such injustices? This is where the critical analysis of the literature comes into play. Nussbaum writes “sympathetic reading and critical reading should go hand in hand, as we ask how our sympathy is being distributed and focused” (101). Finally she addresses the fact that none of us are perfect in self-knowledge, but that an outside perspective is needed to completely understand an issue as some people immersed in the experience fail to see the whole story. Stories about the open closet should be published for many to read about as it will allow more people to observe a perspective they might not otherwise know.

1 comment:

  1. Hey Kelli! Sorry this is late, I got caught up in researching a certain paper that's due tomorrow...

    I'm really glad your experience at The Open Closet has impacted you in such a way. I think it's great when we have these experiences that open our eyes to how tragic the circumstances of some peoples live' are. At the same time, it's depressing because we realize how selfish and how fortunate we are to have been born into the lives we have. As the expression goes, "ignorance is bliss."

    I think that you are write in claiming that these stories need to be told. One of the biggest problems with social work efforts is actually getting people to act. People can feel as empathetic as they want but sympathy doesn't solve any problems. By sharing the stories of these individuals with a large group of people, hopefully the chances of getting a higher percentage of people to act will be greater than only getting a few people to act.

    ReplyDelete