Saturday, October 31, 2009

Presbyterian beliefs and a comparison/contrast to Lutherans, Catholics, and UCC

In my opinion, all of the readings and presentations this far have confirmed Pastor Jay’s conservative/liberal orientation of the denominations: most conservativeà least conservative as Catholics, Lutherans (ELCA), Presbyterians, and UCC. Obviously, it’s easy to put Catholics as most conservative because we are ruled like a monarchy and it takes so long to make any changes in our tradition. It’s also easy to put the UCC as most liberal because each congregation can have its own beliefs, based on a democracy with a voting system. It’s a little more difficult, though, to rank the Lutherans and Presbyterians in my opinion. Because Presbyterians have a balance between clergy and laity in their governing bodies (ie Presbyteries), I consider them more liberal than Lutherans. While Lutherans also vote within their synods, I’m not sure if the voting councils are composed of lay members. I know they are led by a bishop, but I could not find (in the readings or on their website) if lay members were included in these voting synods. However, from my interactions with Pastor Jay, it seems to me like the pastors are most influential in the voting within the synods, making them more conservative than Presbyterians. I think it’s beneficial to keep this in mind when we’re comparing and contrasting religions.

When Joe and Ed explained the governmental hierarchy in the church (sessions, presbyteries, synods, and the General Assembly), I related this both to Lutheranism and to Catholicism. All traditions have some sort of a leadership hierarchy. I have mixed feelings about these hierarchies. I appreciate that we have spiritual leaders who are concerned with the issues and that they discuss how we might fix the social problems. However, if we are truly concerned with human dignity and the poor, I don’t understand why these issues are so controversial. I think that personal agendas too often interfere with making moral and just decisions on issues.

One of the similarities that I noticed between the Presbyterian and Lutheran Churches is that they believe we can be justified by faith alone and that works (like social justice) will flow from this faith. We’ve also seen a common theme among all denominations to protect the rights of the poor and to consider everyone’s human dignity. In addition, Presbyterians and Lutherans are very similar in that neither has solid, black and white positions on individual social issues like the Catholic Church does. For example, neither has a stance on abortion; they believe it is the individual woman’s choice (I wish they would consider the couple here instead of just the woman because it takes two to make a kid!). Another part that doesn’t make much sense to me is with their views on abortion and capital punishment. Both of these social issues involve killing another human being. Sure, capital punishment involves many more people than just a mother and child as well as a full individual, but embryos and fetuses are human beings as well (they just need a little help from the mother first). They have a human dignity that should be respected. While I have never been in the situation, I don’t plan on and hope to never make a decision about an abortion, if I was faced with the circumstance, I hope I would make the decision to give birth and give the child up for adoption. I could go on and on about this…


I like how the Protestant and Orthodox churches have a document relating to social issues of the 21st century. As the Presbyterians say, we are a “Church reformed, always needing reform, according to the Word of God.” So many more issues are present today than were at the time the Bible was written. If we use the guidance of the Bible and spiritual directors, it should be easy to formulate positions on these issues. I really like how they considered the environment in their creed. This is something we all need to be aware of so that the Earth might still be hospitable for life of future generations (and it relates to science: the loss of biodiversity, pollution, global warming and all those topics which interest me). One last thing that I’d like to pull out of the social creed is the line “live simply so others may simply live.” This is the motto for the Franciscan sisters within the Catholic Church. Everyone can apply this to their lives to that we work to create more equal distribution of resources and justice that everyone deserves. I’ll admit, this is something I can work on (and will probably really need to work on in the future), but it’s something that will always remember!

Sunday, October 25, 2009

UCC beliefs and a comparison and contrast to Lutheranism and Catholicism

One of the most striking differences between the UCC and the other denominations we’ve learned about is that the UCC works like a democracy. Each little congregation within the UCC can have different beliefs, depending on the votes within that congregation. This is extremely different from the Catholic Church, as the beliefs are determined by pope, cardinals, and bishops and can be found written in doctrines. The Lutherans also have written beliefs chosen by various synods, but it seems as though the members of the parish can be easily confused about what they are to believe as a Lutheran. Personally, I like belonging to a faith tradition with specific beliefs instead of one that’s a little “wishy-washy.”

I learned that they celebrate 2 sacraments, Baptism and Communion, because those are the ones that Jesus performed. Maybe that’s why Lutherans also only celebrate these two sacraments! They also believe that we should not “play God.” I believe most Christian faith traditions would adhere to this phrase. However, this phrase is a struggle for me as my independent research project is to genetically engineer bacteria to produce a new protein. This is very “unnatural” and requires a lot of manipulation of the bacteria, especially their DNA. Then I’m using the bacteria to have them make the protein for me—seems VERY much like I’m being a creator and playing God. I wonder if the UCC would strike me down for conducting this research.

Also interesting from both the readings and the presentation is their view on imprisonment. I like the views they have—that prisons can function as a place for both rehab and forgiveness. I’m sure the Catholic and Lutheran Churches have similar views, but it’s neat that the UCC incorporates this into their main beliefs. Finally, at the end of the presentation, Carla and Meghan pointed out that the UCC is involved in matters of charity and justice, and takes this one step further to say that justice should be sought so that no one needs any extra help in the first place. This idea is very similar to the CST on the topic of injustice, but I like how Carla and Meghan explained it in their presentation. I’m not sure if that was written in their own words or if it can be found in any UCC documentation…

The UCC and Lutheran beliefs are very similar. They are both a little more “liberal” in their social teachings than Catholics. (By liberal, I mean more accepting to change in the faith tradition as it relates to the secular world.) Changes in the beliefs (not the central beliefs of course, but social beliefs) occur quite often and quite quickly in my mind. This is in contrast to those in the Catholic Church where change is very seldom and takes years to happen because we are a worldwide institution run like a monarchy. I really like how both are a little more realistic than the Catholic tradition in that they either recognize that we live in a fallen world and aren’t perfect (Lutheranism) or that they believe that God is still speaking to us (UCC). Personally, I prefer the “Lutheran social teaching” over that of the UCC mainly because each congregation is taught to have the same beliefs. In the UCC, the beliefs can vary between congregations, and that doesn’t seem like a solid faith to me. In regards to my faith struggle I’ve been dealing with, I really feel like I’m practicing the right faith for me right now; I still have questions to my beliefs, but questions are good!

Sunday, October 11, 2009

Updated Service Plan

The four main learning goals I originally created for this class are:
1. understand how people in the neighborhood live their day to day lives and compare and contrast it to mine
2. see more of a community in the neighborhood (both at the churches and in the very nice neighborhood parks)
3. understand the lives of people with really low income as it will relate to my future profession in optometry, and
4. strengthen my commitment to service!

Now that I have been active in St. John’s parish with the health ministry, and communicating with members, I would like to revise those original goals. One of the biggest challenges that I see myself faced with is interacting with people of the neighborhood who are not members (or active members) of St. John’s. By serving others through St. John’s health ministry, I have not yet been exposed to anyone outside of the congregation. Hopefully in the near future (with the flu shot clinic) I will be able to interact with individuals who do not identify with St. John’s so that I can work to achieve my original #1 and #3 goals! Along these same lines, I also think it will be very difficult to create a sense of community among all the people living in the Washington neighborhood. A better idea might be to have more creative ways of inviting the outside community into the various parishes. If we can somehow get more involvement in these churches, and then work to create dialogue between the churches (like Joe proposed), then I think we will be able to create this sense of community! The avenue we would use to get there is the church!!

So to formulate my new goals….
1. Through the health ministry (and other projects we work on as a class), determine which people actually live in the neighborhood. Plan to converse with them to understand how they live their life. Also, ask them questions about justice and maybe even what they think of their life in general.
2. Continue working on the community outreach programs that St. John’s offers. From being persistent with these programs as well as acting as Christ towards others, the individuals in the community my learn the importance of faith communities; hopefully more and more will attend services. If we also open up the communication lines between the parishes, we could really create some community!!!
3. As I participate in the health ministry and converse with those from the neighborhood, ask them about the difficulty with receiving quality health care (if any). [pastor jay told us a story about one member who needs health care from physicians because he has seizures, but does not have health insurance. To get care, he has to travel to U of I!! I would like to get an idea of how often this happens (he made it sound frequent). By I might have a difficult time determining this since I don’t interact with all the members in the community.]
4. Strengthen my commitment to service! This one can stay exactly the same, and I already see my commitment strengthening!!

Some new ways St. John’s plans to connect with the neighborhood include the creation of a soup kitchen, establishing a martial arts class (along with a spiritual component of course), and Spanish classes. It sounds like this soup kitchen is a “project on hold.” We have expressed our interest to help begin the program, but are not given any direction on where to help Abe in his efforts. I’m not so sure we, as a class, should put our efforts into this project because of the lack of organization and because there is already a place to eat every night of the week. One member of the parish has decided to begin a martial arts class. I know nothing about martial arts, so I don’t think I’d be much of a help with this project! Plus, I didn’t hear it from the source; other members told me that this man only has the idea, so I don’t know how committed he is. The last idea interests me the most! One member told me this morning that there are English classes offered (where: I don’t know) to people in the community who do not speak English as their first language. I thought this was great! What the members said they would like to see, though, is a Spanish class for them to learn the basics and communicate (at least a little) with those who have Spanish as a first language! One man said he knows a little Spanish (he did pretty well and I understood him) only because that’s how he has to communicate with some of the people who come through the open closet. Other members are interested in learning the basics—I took 4 years in high school, one semester in college, lived with Jime’s mom (who speaks about 10 words in English) for a month and tried to communicate with her, and traveled to Costa Rica, brushing up on my Spanish. Maybe I could help in facilitation of this “Spanish course” for the members of St. John’s! I just might need to find someone else who’s a little more fluent than I am first! It would be beneficial to open this limited Spanish communication for both the members of St. John’s and for those who know very little English!

Yesterday, Crystal and I had a very nice (and long) meeting with Pastor Jay. It was great to learn more about Lutheran Social teachings in comparison to what I believe as a Catholic. It made me question some things we believe in as Catholics. As much as I hate going from feeling "sound" in my religion to questioning it, I got a lot out of the meeting and am in the process of searching for answers! It's good to have a little "religious vulnerability" sometimes (I hope and think).

Today we went to a service and met some really nice people! I loved the conversations we had, and the people were overwhelmingly nice! I hope I can find a parish with just as nice people as this next year in the city!!!

Saturday, October 3, 2009

Dialogue on Catholic Social Teaching: from a Catholic to a Lutheran

If I had to give a brief talk on Catholic Social Teaching to the leaders of St. John’s, I would articulate that most of their mission coincides with that of CST. They do a fair job of meeting human needs and providing to those who have little. For example, the mission of the open closet agrees with what is written in Himes, chapter 3. CST claims that “we ought to attend to the needs of the least advantaged before we turn our attention to the agenda of the better off” (39). The individuals that receive these free clothes from the closet certainly have a lesser advantage than the ones who donated to the cause. I’m sure this charitable work is appreciated by many people in the community! I would also read them section number 257 on page 125 of Mater et Magistra to commend them on the wonderful charitable works! That passage gives a great description of charity and the leaders of this organization should read it! If they ever get this soup kitchen up and running, I would compliment them for providing another avenue to reach out to those in most need of the service!

I would also compliment them on their health ministry as it relates to CST. The health services that are provided truly do fulfill a human need. I would direct Pastor Jay and Shirley Cocayne to part II of Mater et Magistera and read “all sorts of consumer goods and services, closely connected with the needs of the body and more especially the spirit are short in supply…the attainment of such goods and services provides remarkable opportunity and stimulus for individuals…” (93). As I have discussed with them and read in their pamphlet, the purpose of this health ministry is three fold: healing of the mind, healing of the body and healing of the spirit. Without all three components (particularly the spirit), the effect of the health ministry would be diminished. Most other health care providers leave this important part of spirit out of their healing process! Also, as mentioned in Gaudium et Spes section 43, it is important that Shirley is using her expertise in the health profession to fulfill the mission of the health ministry.

To wrap up the positive aspects of their ministry, I would direct them to a quote which relates the role of public authorities and social living. The areas of concern for public authorities are “the care of health, the instruction and education of youth, the choice of a personal career, the ways and means of rehabilitating or assisting those handicapped mentally or physically” (93). Although a church is not a public authority (at least in my opinion), they fill these roles, and I would commend them for that! St. John’s health ministry, Sunday school for the youth, career opportunities within the parish, and mental health outreach through the both the basic ministry of the church and the health ministry within the church are ways in which they work to improve the lives of those in their community. They are fulfilling the mission of all Christian churches: to proclaim the rights of all by using the words of the Gospel (O’Brien and Shannon 191).

The one place where I would suggest room for improvement is with creating a sense of community. Although I have not performed much service to date, I do not get the impression that they have a deep sense of community either within the church’s community or within the neighborhood community. Sure they have various programs, but to me it doesn’t seem that they are truly connected. It’s more of a once a week meeting rather than community interest from what I’ve seen. I would direct the leaders to chapter three in Himes, where it mentions “human beings are not meant to live in isolation but are meant to live in community with each other” (25). It is in our human nature that we create loving communities around us, and only flourish when connected to these communities. It is important they these people come together and create a community on which they can depend! As we continue in our technological advances, many more ways of reaching out to the community have been opened! Section 6 in Gaudium et Spes (169) explains that many new forms of media can be used to communicate to members, spreading the message quickly as chain reactions take off easily from these new forms of communication. I would tell Pastor Jay that a website seems like it would be effective for membership and donations, and that he should consider pursuing this idea!

One way to create a deeper sense of community that can continue for generations is to target the youth. To assist in this explanation I would direct them to Part IV of Mater et Magistera. To promote the Christian law for generations to come, the adult leaders must first train themselves in the practice in order to effectively communicate with and teach the youth the importance of the law (121). While St. John’s does have a Sunday school program, I feel that they could be doing a little more outreach with the children to increase “retention rates” in the future! This problem of the change in attitudes of young people in religion is outlined nicely in section 7 on page 169 of Gaudium et Spes. I would direct Pastor Jay to this so that he understands this is probably a universal challenge, but it’s possible to overcome if they work to defeat it!

In expressing my thoughts to them, I would not pick large portions of text to read to them, just small quotes here and there to get my point across. (See quotes mentioned next to each topic above and how they relate to each topic.) Since I don’t know too many members of the parish, it would be difficult for me to break them into groups for discussion. Of course for the health ministry, I would speak with Pastor Jay and Shirley, for the open closet to Pastor Jay and Terry Krier and Pastor Jay with any other interested members for most other topics!