One of the most striking differences between the UCC and the other denominations we’ve learned about is that the UCC works like a democracy. Each little congregation within the UCC can have different beliefs, depending on the votes within that congregation. This is extremely different from the Catholic Church, as the beliefs are determined by pope, cardinals, and bishops and can be found written in doctrines. The Lutherans also have written beliefs chosen by various synods, but it seems as though the members of the parish can be easily confused about what they are to believe as a Lutheran. Personally, I like belonging to a faith tradition with specific beliefs instead of one that’s a little “wishy-washy.”
I learned that they celebrate 2 sacraments, Baptism and Communion, because those are the ones that Jesus performed. Maybe that’s why Lutherans also only celebrate these two sacraments! They also believe that we should not “play God.” I believe most Christian faith traditions would adhere to this phrase. However, this phrase is a struggle for me as my independent research project is to genetically engineer bacteria to produce a new protein. This is very “unnatural” and requires a lot of manipulation of the bacteria, especially their DNA. Then I’m using the bacteria to have them make the protein for me—seems VERY much like I’m being a creator and playing God. I wonder if the UCC would strike me down for conducting this research.
Also interesting from both the readings and the presentation is their view on imprisonment. I like the views they have—that prisons can function as a place for both rehab and forgiveness. I’m sure the Catholic and Lutheran Churches have similar views, but it’s neat that the UCC incorporates this into their main beliefs. Finally, at the end of the presentation, Carla and Meghan pointed out that the UCC is involved in matters of charity and justice, and takes this one step further to say that justice should be sought so that no one needs any extra help in the first place. This idea is very similar to the CST on the topic of injustice, but I like how Carla and Meghan explained it in their presentation. I’m not sure if that was written in their own words or if it can be found in any UCC documentation…
The UCC and Lutheran beliefs are very similar. They are both a little more “liberal” in their social teachings than Catholics. (By liberal, I mean more accepting to change in the faith tradition as it relates to the secular world.) Changes in the beliefs (not the central beliefs of course, but social beliefs) occur quite often and quite quickly in my mind. This is in contrast to those in the Catholic Church where change is very seldom and takes years to happen because we are a worldwide institution run like a monarchy. I really like how both are a little more realistic than the Catholic tradition in that they either recognize that we live in a fallen world and aren’t perfect (Lutheranism) or that they believe that God is still speaking to us (UCC). Personally, I prefer the “Lutheran social teaching” over that of the UCC mainly because each congregation is taught to have the same beliefs. In the UCC, the beliefs can vary between congregations, and that doesn’t seem like a solid faith to me. In regards to my faith struggle I’ve been dealing with, I really feel like I’m practicing the right faith for me right now; I still have questions to my beliefs, but questions are good!
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

The UCC seems very open to new ideas, so I would be very surprised if they were upset with you for making the world a better place with science. I think their idea of "playing God" had more to do with deciding who should live and who should die. They were very against death and destruction. Though I supposed science does have death and destruction, it also helps create life and make life better for others. I would guess that at least on a national level, science is very supported by the UCC.
ReplyDeleteThe idea of justice is actually one that the UCC supports. I can't remember how we worded it, but the one you wrote was very much emphasized in everything I both read and heard from Pastor Sue. The church doesn't think that charity is enough (although it's also important) and that if you ignore fixing the problem then you aren't really working to make the world better.
I do agree that the church, with all its congregations able to choose their own beliefs, loses something. When I heard that I thought "Why have a national council at all?" It would be difficult to go to a new town and wonder what THAT new church believed in...