Sunday, September 13, 2009

Socrates, Plato, and Kant, Oh My!

Although I have already taken many of my advanced general education courses at Loras, I still do not know much about philosophy. The philosophical names of Socrates, Plato and Kant have always intimidated me because I know so little about them. In my values course last year, I learned about Utilitarianism, Principalism, Kant, and couple of other theories that guide ethical decision making. However, we talked very little about Socrates, Plato and other philosophers. After reading the chapter on Socratic Self-examination I know a little bit more about who these figures are and what principles they believe in.

Prior to reading this chapter, I thought that “liberal arts” was a general term used to describe a well-rounded education. This “liberal arts” education is in contrast to an education focused on one specific topic. For example, my goal is to get a degree in biochemistry. If I would have attended a large state university, I would have taken semesters filled with science courses because the topics fascinate me and I love to learn about science and the world around us. A very small amount of my courses would have been outside the realm of science, with the sole purpose of completing graduate school pre-requisites. In contrast to this, Loras is educating me in several other areas. In addition to the numerous courses in science, I have taken courses in history, writing, speaking, religion, ethics (with a little philosophy), and culture to name a few.

While many of these courses I am taking outside of the science hall do not interest me, I do believe they have and will continue to help me in life. From science courses, I can learn the facts and theories about the world and use them to create new ideas. To be an active citizen in my community, I need to be able to expand those skills. The general education courses at Loras have strengthened my ability to reason and make judgments and decisions. This is a critical task that I will need as I continue my career path in optometry. I feel that the curriculum has also strengthened my communication skills through the various discussions and debates offered in these courses. I just completed an interview for optometry school; they accepted me because of my academic record along with my exceptional interpersonal skills. I believe these skills can, at least in some part, be attributed to the general education curriculum at Loras.

After reading the first chapter in Nussbaum, I learned that the term “liberal arts” means much more than I described in the previous paragraph. She adds that at least one course with a philosophy background should be required (if not strongly encouraged) so that students receiving a liberal arts education can reason effectively. She uses Socrates’ philosophies to (ironically) argue that critical and reflective thinking must be employed to formulate one’s position on a controversy. I think it’s so neat that reflective thinking just happens to be one of the dispositions of the college! She describes the liberal arts education as “an essential tool of civic freedom” because students learn to think independently, but yet work with the community to “genuinely reason together about a problem, not simply trade claims and counterclaims” (19). It is important to learn this process of reasoning because it is precisely the method of argumentation that will be used when one moves on from a liberal arts college and enters the “real world.” Using these skills to contribute to society relates to being a responsible contributor (another one of those 4 dispositions)! Nussbaum writes that the arguing skills gained from a liberal arts education will continue to be used through life as we live in a democratic society.

Even though many colleges and universities are implementing liberal arts into their curriculum, there are still opponents. Nussbaum discusses two of her opponents. First is the “conservative opposition.” The individuals in this group claim that liberal arts weaken traditional values. I think part of this opposition is because we are exposed to and learn about various cultures and traditions around the world when receiving a liberal arts education. With this exposure, we are naturally inclined to examine and question our own beliefs. Even though questioning one’s faith might seem to weaken it, the questioning most often leads to a deeper understanding of and belief in that particular faith. The second group believes that minorities such as women and racial minorities are suited for arguing. They believe that these minorities do not have power, so their argumentation will be lost. However, because logical reasoning is natural for humans, we know these minorities can very well participate in and benefit from the debates within a liberal arts education.

The argumentative process used in liberal arts courses can prepare people for service. The process used in arguing requires that one must critically reflect on their claims to support their final judgment. This reflection process can be applied to service. While contributing service to a group with a background different than our own, we might find ourselves questioning and reflecting on our own beliefs. Because we have already learned how to reflect critically with a liberal arts education, I expect that the service reflection process will only strengthen our beliefs and ideas! Hopefully, we will learn about the lives of people who have it much more difficult than us and our eyes are opened!

1 comment:

  1. Kelli, I wouldn't worry too much about not being familiar with philosophy. As a philosophy minor I can gurantee you that many ideas of even the philosophers disucssed in the reading are still foreign to me. I had the same thoughts about liberal education as you. I really think it's just a way to make us more well-rounded. However, after doing a bit more thinking sometimes I wonder if that's just silly. Isn't high school supposed to make us well-rounded and college prepare us for a career? I don't know, just a thought.

    I'm glad that you have found your gen ed classes at Loras helpful. It's always a plus when you actually learn something. Oh, and CONGRATS on being accepted to optometry school!!!! That is very exciting.

    Alot of what Nussbaum said in her book is reflected through Loras' 4 dispositions. That might explain why I'm pretty positive I've read other works written by her for like three other classes. I liked her idea of requiring some kind of philosophy or ethics class. I think it's important to make people think about why they believe the stuff they do. It can either help reinforce their beliefs, or it may help them realize an error in the way the think about something. Which you also said. Yeah we agree!

    ReplyDelete